What if Monday Wasn't a Fresh Start?
Updated: Nov 9
I'll Start Again Monday
Whenever I start a new nutrition program, I have the best of intentions. I grocery shop on the weekend, filling the house with all fresh food and doing my best to avoid sugar. I get a burst of motivation to meal prep on Sunday, cutting up vegetables, washing and filling the fruit bowl, organizing snacks and preparing breakfasts for the week ahead. And then comes my ‘final’ meal on Sunday night, normally something more indulgent, topped off with one last cookie.
Come Monday, I am ready!
Monday is great. Everything goes according to plan, and I eat all the meals I am supposed to. Okay, I might be a little hungry, and may not have liked that kale salad for dinner, but I made it through.
Tuesday morning, wake up and motivated to start another day. Egg whites for breakfast, check. Salad with chicken for lunch, check. By 3 p.m. I’m a little hungry. A few nuts won’t hurt right? They’re healthy fats, after all. Come dinner time, everything is back on track and I make the decision I have been ‘good’ all day and can finish with a cookie…or two.
Then comes the invitation to go out for dinner on Wednesday, followed by a busy day on Thursday, missing lunch and eating whatever I can at dinner to make up for it. Slowly the week continues to progress like this and each day there is a new slide. By the weekend you say “whatever! I’ll start again on Monday!”
Recognize the pattern?
We’ve all been there. Find me someone who hasn’t said, “I will start again on Monday”. It's very common and in fact isn't relegated to diet and exercise. However, this way of thinking starts to create habits of its own. The “I’ll take the weekends off” habit. The “I’ll try again tomorrow” habit. The “I’ve been good today I deserve a little treat” habit. Before long, these patterns begin to undermine our best intentions, and we find ourselves starting yet another program, hoping this time will be different. Over the years, I have found that starting over every Monday is like that old saying–the definition of insanity in the dictionary–doing the same thing over and over again expecting a different result.
Perhaps the problem isn't that we keep falling off track but instead it's that we keep setting ourselves up with plans or programs that don’t leave much room for real life.
Our intentions are rarely the issue. Often we imagine a week where we have the time to prepare every meal, eat at regular hours and make all the decisions we promised ourselves we would. But then life happens. An unexpected dinner invitation, a busy afternoon or simply not feeling like eating what we’ve prepared. Suddenly, we become faced with real life decisions battling between following the plan or enjoying whatever life has presented us with. We choose the latter and feel as though we’ve failed.
This is where we need to change our approach.
Eating well shouldn't mean giving up the things we enjoy, having a perfectly organized week or missing out on living life just to stay on track. Nor should one unexpected meal mean we have to start all over again.
If there is one thing my years of experience has taught me, it’s that there is no single approach to nutrition that works for everyone. The most effective approach isn’t necessarily the most structured or restrictive. It's the one that takes into account your preferences, your routines and the demands of your everyday life.
Because ultimately, eating well should fit into the life you're living, not require you to rearrange your life around it.
Take it With You
The next time you find yourself thinking, "I'll start again on Monday," stop and ask yourself why.
Was it because you enjoyed a meal out, ate something you hadn't planned or simply had a day that didn't go as expected?
Rather than treating these moments as setbacks, consider what they can teach you about your habits and expectations. One meal or one day doesn't undo all the positive choices you've made.
This week, instead of trying to change 50 things at once, choose one small habit you can realistically maintain. When I work with clients, one of the first things I often encourage them to do is drink more water. It's a simple place to start, but yours might be making time for breakfast or eating a more satisfying lunch.
Whatever you choose, give yourself time to make it part of your routine before adding something else.
Consistency isn't about getting everything right. It's about finding a way to keep going, even when life doesn't go according to plan.
